Prepare for UPSC with Confidence – Explore Free Quizzes, Study Material, and Expert Guidance!

27 May 2025 Daily Current Affairs

Context: In a historic economic milestone, India has surpassed Japan to become the world’s fourth-largest economy by nominal GDP, according to a recent announcement by NITI Aayog CEO B.V.R. Subrahmanyam. India’s nominal GDP now stands at $4.19 trillion, narrowly outpacing Japan’s $4.18 trillion, as per the latest estimates.

With this achievement, India is firmly on track to displace Germany and claim the third spot by 2028, backed by consistent economic growth and proactive reforms.

India’s Economic Surge: Powered by Growth and Reform

  • India’s economic momentum is among the strongest globally. According to the IMF’s World Economic Outlook, India is projected to grow at 6.2% in 2025 and 6.3% in 2026, maintaining its position as the fastest-growing major economy.
  • In just a decade, India has doubled its GDP from $2.1 trillion in 2015 to over $4.19 trillion in 2025, marking an unprecedented rise in global financial stature.

Path to Becoming the Third-Largest Economy:

  • The IMF estimates that India will likely overtake Germany by 2028, when India’s GDP is projected to reach $5.5 trillion. Meanwhile, Germany’s economy is expected to stagnate, with 0% growth in 2025 and only 0.9% in 2026, largely due to global trade tensions and internal economic challenges.

Key Drivers of India’s Economic Ascent:

  1. Expanding Domestic Consumption: India’s growth is significantly supported by robust consumer demand, particularly in rural areas. Rapid urbanization, coupled with rising incomes, is driving a consumption-led boom. India’s urban population is projected to hit 600 million by 2030, creating a vast consumer base.
  2. Demographic Advantage:  With a median age of 29, India enjoys a demographic dividend, offering a young, productive workforce that could fuel long-term growth.
  3. Infrastructure & Digital Evolution:  Massive public investment in infrastructure, including transportation, logistics, and digital connectivity, is transforming the economic landscape. Initiatives like Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI), Gati Shakti, and PM-WANI have made India a leader in digital governance and public service delivery.
  4. Rise of Manufacturing & Services:  India’s manufacturing sector has gained traction under schemes like Make in India and the Production-Linked Incentive (PLI) program. Simultaneously, the IT and financial services sectors continue to dominate, contributing heavily to GDP and exports.
  5. Global Strategic Shifts:  With the world embracing the “China Plus One” strategy, India is emerging as a preferred alternative for global manufacturing. Major multinational corporations, such as Apple, are now setting up production units in India, accelerating FDI inflows and boosting domestic capacity.
  6. Reforms and Policy Initiatives:  Reforms such as the Goods and Services Tax (GST), Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), and corporate tax reductions have significantly enhanced ease of doing business

Programs like Atmanirbhar Bharat, National Infrastructure Pipeline (NIP), and PM Gati Shakti have spurred capital formation and improved productivity.

Additional Insight: Real GDP vs Nominal GDP:

  • Nominal GDP reflects the current market value of all goods and services without adjusting for inflation.
  • Real GDP, on the other hand, adjusts for inflation, offering a clearer picture of actual growth in production.

India’s current ranking is based on nominal GDP, which is useful for comparing global economic influence.

Challenges on the Road Ahead:

  1. Geopolitical Tensions: Global conflicts, trade disruptions, and supply chain bottlenecks pose risks to India’s open and export-oriented economy.
  2. Inflation Concerns: While headline inflation has declined, services inflation remains stubborn, and volatile commodity prices—especially food and fuel—continue to pressure household budgets.
  3. Employment and Skill Gaps: The rise of automation, AI, and digital technologies demands continuous upskilling of India’s workforce to stay relevant in a changing labor market.
  4. Export and Trade Deficit Pressures:  India’s current account deficit has narrowed to 1% of GDP, but weak global demand has impacted export growth. There’s an urgent need to diversify trade partnerships.
  5. Infrastructure Investment Needs: Though India’s Capex-to-GDP ratio has risen to 3.3%, sustained investment is essential to build modern logistics, power grids, and rural connectivity.

Way Forward: Strategies for Sustained Growth:

  • Expand Global Trade Footprints: Strengthen trade relationships with Southeast Asia, Africa, and Latin America to reduce dependency on traditional markets.
  • Boost Domestic Manufacturing: Scale initiatives like Make in India to reduce import dependency and build resilient supply chains.
  • Embrace Green and Digital Transformation: Invest in clean energy, digital tools, and AI-led innovation to foster inclusive and sustainable development.
  • Foster Inclusive Growth: Create policies that ensure financial inclusion, rural development, and gender equity to make growth more broad-based.

Conclusion: India’s Moment on the Global Stage

India’s rise to become the fourth-largest global economy marks a pivotal moment in its journey toward economic superpower status. With strategic reforms, youthful energy, and digital leadership, the nation is well-positioned to shape the future of the global economy.

Context: In a surprising update, the Ministry of Home Affairs in its 2023–24 report has revised India’s total coastline length to 11,098.8 km, a major jump from the earlier figure of 7,516.6 km. But this increase has nothing to do with territorial expansion or land reclamation. Instead, the jump highlights an intriguing mathematical phenomenon known as the “coastline paradox.”

Understanding the Coastline Paradox:

The coastline paradox reveals that the length of a coastline depends on how precisely it’s measured. The finer the scale (or smaller the measuring unit), the longer the coastline appears.

  • Euclidean Geometry, used in traditional mapping, assumes smooth lines and curves, making coastlines appear shorter.
  • But in reality, coastlines are jagged, irregular, and fractal-like. They have self-similar patterns that repeat at various scales—a concept rooted in Fractal Geometry, introduced by Benoît Mandelbrot.
  • In theory, if one were to measure the coastline down to the size of a water molecule, the length could approach infinity. That’s the paradox.

This revision, therefore, reflects mathematical accuracy, not physical expansion.

New-Age Mapping: Precision Meets Technology:

The extended coastline is the result of cutting-edge mapping technologies and a more refined methodology, spearheaded by agencies like the National Hydrographic Office (NHO) and the Survey of India.

What’s New in the Measurement Process?

  • Finer Scale: Mapping at a 1:250,000 resolution using Electronic Navigation Charts.
  • Advanced Tech: Utilized GIS, satellite altimetry, LIDAR-GPS, and drone-based imaging.
  • Highwater Line Reference: Based on 2011 tide data, giving a more accurate representation of the coast.
  • River Mouth Closure: Rivers and creeks were “closed” at a fixed inland point to prevent artificial inflation.
  • Islands Counted: Even tidal islands exposed during low tide were added to the total.
  • Scheduled Updates: From 2024–25 onward, this data will be revised every 10 years, ensuring continuous accuracy.

Why This Matters: Implications of a Longer Coastline

  1. Strengthened Disaster Resilience: India’s eastern coast is frequently hit by cyclones and tsunamis—think Cyclone Fani or Yaas.

More accurate coastal maps improve:

  • Early warning systems
  • Evacuation planning
  • Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) demarcations

This helps build climate-resilient infrastructure in vulnerable areas.

  1. Boosting the Blue Economy: 

A longer coastline enhances the scope of India’s Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ), opening doors to:

  • Offshore energy (wind, oil, gas)
  • Marine fisheries and aquaculture
  • Bioprospecting
  • Deep-sea mining

This supports major initiatives like Sagarmala, Bharatmala, and port-led industrial corridors.

3. Better Urban Planning and Coastal Governance: Updated coastline data feeds into:

  • Urban zoning laws
  • Port planning and dredging
  • Shoreline management programs

Coastal states like Tamil Nadu, Odisha, Gujarat, and Kerala can now make more informed investment and infrastructure decisions.

Key Challenges and the Road Ahead: 

  1. Constantly Changing Coastlines: 

Coastlines are dynamic systems, shaped by:

  • Tidal action
  • Sediment transport
  • Erosion and deposition
  • Sea-level rise

This makes periodic revisions essential to maintain up-to-date coastal maps.

  1. Need for Cross-Agency Collaboration:

Effective coastal management requires seamless coordination among multiple agencies:

  • National Hydrographic Office
  • Survey of India
  • Ministry of Earth Sciences
  • Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change
  1. Investing in Technology: Continued upgrades in mapping technologies—such as hyperspectral imaging, AI-powered data analytics, and real-time satellite monitoring—are crucial.
  2. Capacity Building: There’s an urgent need to train and upskill professionals in:
  • Coastal engineering
  • Environmental science
  • Geospatial technologies

to manage and secure India’s long and vital coastline.

Interesting Fact: India’s Maritime Legacy

India has a rich maritime history dating back to Indus Valley ports like Lothal. Today, with 13 major ports and 200+ minor ports, India’s coast plays a pivotal role in trade, culture, and connectivity.

Conclusion: Precision Unlocks Potential

The revision of India’s coastline from 7,516.6 km to 11,098.8 km is more than a number—it’s a reflection of scientific accuracy, technological progress, and better governance. By embracing the mathematics behind nature, India is better prepared to manage disasters, grow its blue economy, and plan smarter cities—all while preserving its precious coastal ecosystems.

Context: In a key diplomatic engagement, the Foreign Minister of Maldives arrived in New Delhi to participate in the 2nd High-Level Core Group (HLCG) Meeting. The discussions aim to review the progress made under the India–Maldives Vision Document for a Comprehensive Economic and Maritime Security Partnership, jointly adopted by Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the President of Maldives last year.

Core Areas of Cooperation: Vision for a Shared Future

The meeting reflects a shared ambition to strengthen bilateral ties with a people-first and future-ready approach. The partnership spans across multiple domains:

  1. Bilateral Commitment and Financial Support: India has reaffirmed its regional priority under the ‘Neighbourhood First’ policy and Vision SAGAR (Security and Growth for All in the Region). In a show of economic solidarity:
  • India provided emergency financial aid through:
    • Rollover of $100 million in Treasury Bills
    • Currency swap worth $400 million
    • 30 billion in budgetary support

This support underlines India’s role as a reliable development partner for Maldives in times of financial stress.

  1. A Framework for Comprehensive Economic & Maritime Security Partnership: 

The newly structured framework envisions:

  • A strategic, stabilizing force in the Indian Ocean Region
  • A focus on mutual prosperity, security, and resilience
  • A people-centric approach to ensure long-term development
  1. Development and Infrastructure Cooperation:  India has stepped up its commitment to nation-building projects in Maldives, including:
  • Ports, roads, airports, hospitals, housing, and schools
  • Major initiatives like the Greater Male Connectivity Project (GMCP), worth USD 530 million, will connect Male to Thilafushi, Villingili, and Gulhifalhu, and act as a major catalyst for Maldivian economic development.

4. Trade and Economic Partnership: 

Efforts are underway to explore:

  • A potential Bilateral Free Trade Agreement (FTA)
  • Local currency trade settlement to reduce dollar reliance
  • Encouragement of private investments and improved ease of doing business
  • Support for economic diversification, particularly in:
    • Blue economy
  • Fisheries
  • Ocean-based research and innovation
  1. Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI): 

India is sharing its expertise in digital transformation, including:

  • Expansion of UPI, RuPay, and Digital ID systems
  • Support for fintech ecosystems and digital governance tools
  • Collaboration in implementing platforms like Gati Shakti
  1. Clean Energy and Environment: Both countries are aligning on sustainability through:
  • Renewable energy projects, especially solar power
  • Participation in India’s One Sun One World One Grid initiative
  • Joint research, training, and investment in energy efficiency
  1. Healthcare and Pharmaceuticals: India continues to be a key healthcare partner for the Maldives:
  • Access to affordable Indian healthcare services
  • Export and availability of generic medicines through Jan Aushadhi Kendras
  • Recognition of Indian Pharmacopoeia, improving drug regulation standards

8. Maritime and Regional Security Cooperation: 

Both sides agreed to bolster:

  • Maritime domain awareness
  • Coordination through the Colombo Security Conclave (CSC)
  • Cooperation in multilateral fora to uphold regional peace and stability

India remains Maldives’ primary security partner, but with an approach that respects Maldivian sovereignty and preferences.

Institutional Mechanism for Implementation:

To ensure effective execution of all agreements and frameworks:

  • A High-Level Core Group (HLCG) has been established
  • The group includes senior officials from both nations and will monitor progress across all sectors

Significance of the India–Maldives Relationship:

Regional Importance:

  • Maldives is strategically located in the heart of the Indian Ocean, making it vital to India’s maritime security and trade routes.

Economic Leadership:

  • In 2023, India emerged as Maldives’ largest trading partner.
  • India is a top investor and source of tourism, contributing to over 11.8% of tourist arrivals in 2023.

Defense Cooperation:

  • India has been Maldives’ defense partner since 1988, providing:
    • Training for over 70% of Maldivian defence personnel
    • Support under the 2016 Defence Action Plan

Connectivity Boost:

  • The Open Skies Agreement (2022) has enhanced air links, facilitating trade, tourism, and people-to-people ties.

The Road Ahead: Towards MAHASAGAR Vision

Maldives remains a core maritime neighbour under India’s strategic MAHASAGAR visionMutual and Holistic Advancement for Security and Growth Across Regions.

Moving forward, the emphasis will be on:

  • Balancing strategic autonomy with shared interests
  • Deepening cooperation in climate resilience, tech innovation, and blue economy
  • Ensuring maritime safety, economic growth, and regional stability

Conclusion: A Relationship Anchored in Trust and Shared Goals

The 2nd HLCG Meeting has further strengthened the India–Maldives partnership, laying the groundwork for mutually beneficial cooperation across sectors. As the Indian Ocean becomes increasingly geopolitically significant, this dynamic and evolving relationship stands as a model of regional diplomacy, resilience, and responsible leadership.

4. Oil Spill Crisis off Kerala Coast: A Wake-Up Call for Marine Protection

Context: A significant environmental emergency has unfolded off the Kerala coast following the sinking of the Liberian-flagged cargo vessel MSC ELSA 3, approximately 14 nautical miles from the shoreline. The ship’s descent has triggered a major oil spill, threatening marine biodiversity and coastal livelihoods.

The Indian Coast Guard has swiftly mobilized resources, including the ICGS Saksham and Dornier surveillance aircraft, to contain and manage the spill.

Understanding Oil Spills: A Hidden Menace

An oil spill occurs when liquid petroleum hydrocarbons leak into the marine ecosystem, either due to shipping accidents, pipeline failures, offshore drilling mishaps, or refinery leaks.

These spills involve various harmful substances:

  • Crude oil
  • Refined fuels like diesel and petrol
  • Heavy bunker oil used by large ships
  • Oily residues or waste

Environmental and Economic Consequences:

Oil spills are catastrophic in their impact, not only to marine life but also to human communities:

Damage to Marine Life:

  • Oil coats the gills of fish, feathers of birds, and fur of mammals, impairing their mobility and survival.
  • It disrupts breeding and feeding patterns, leading to population decline.

Destruction of Coastal Habitats:

  • Mangroves, beaches, and coral reefs absorb the oil, leading to long-term degradation.
  • Sensitive ecosystems may take decades to recover.

Impact on Fisheries and Aquaculture:

  • Contaminated waters cause a collapse in fish stocks.
  • Damages fishing equipment and threatens livelihoods of coastal communities.

Hit to Tourism:

  • Oil-laden shores deter visitors, leading to a steep decline in coastal tourism, a major income source for Kerala.

Health Hazards:

  • Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) and other toxic compounds in oil can cause:
    • Respiratory issues
    • Skin irritation
    • Neurological effects
    • Long-term cancer risk through seafood consumption

Notable Oil Spills: Global and Indian Examples

International Incidents:

  • Deepwater Horizon (2010, Gulf of Mexico): Largest marine spill in history.
  • MV Wakashio (2020, Mauritius): Caused ecological destruction near a marine park.
  • Venezuela (2020): El Palito refinery leak.
  • Norilsk, Russia (2020): Diesel fuel spill in the Arctic.

Major Indian Spills:

  • Chennai (2017): Two ships collided, causing a massive spill near Kamarajar Port.
  • Mumbai (2010): 800 tonnes of oil spilled after ship collision.
  • ONGC Uran (2013): Leak into the Arabian Sea.
  • Sundarbans (2014): Sela River spill in Bangladesh threatened India’s mangrove biodiversity.

Global Response: International Frameworks

MARPOL (1973): The International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships mandates stringent standards for maritime pollution control.

India is a signatory and adheres to its protocols.

Oil Pollution Preparedness and Response Convention (1990):

  • Promotes global cooperation, information exchange, and emergency preparedness among nations to tackle major spills effectively.

India’s Strategy: National Preparedness and Legal Measures

National Oil Spill Disaster Contingency Plan (NOS-DCP):

  • Enforced by the Indian Coast Guard
  • Originally framed in 1996, revised in 2015
  • Key Goals:
    • Quick incident reporting
    • Rapid containment and recovery
    • Public health and marine ecosystem protection
    • Integration of technology and science

Merchant Shipping Act, 1958:

  • Grants the central government authority to take action against vessels that violate maritime safety norms.
  • Enables penal action against shipowners responsible for spills.

Control and Clean-Up Technologies:

Bioremediation:

  • Use of oil-degrading microorganisms to naturally break down pollutants.
  • TERI’s “Oil Zapper” is a pioneering microbial solution developed in India.

Oil Booms:

  • Floating barriers that contain and prevent the spread of oil slicks on water surfaces.

Dispersants:

  • Chemicals sprayed via aircraft or boats that break oil into small droplets, enhancing natural degradation.

In Situ Burning:

  • Controlled burning of thick oil layers at sea to minimize residue.

Skimming:

  • Mechanical method using specialized vessels and equipment to remove oil from the water surface.

Additional Insights: Kerala’s Marine Ecosystem at Risk

Kerala’s coast is rich in:

  • Mangrove forests
  • Coral patches near Lakshadweep
  • Commercial fish species (sardines, mackerel, prawns)

A spill here threatens not just the local ecosystem, but national fish exports, and the livelihoods of thousands of artisanal fishers.

Conclusion: Time for Proactive Marine Governance

The oil spill near Kerala is a reminder of the fragility of our coasts and the need for proactive environmental safeguards.

India must:

  • Invest in satellite surveillance, AI-based prediction models, and cross-border alert systems
  • Conduct mock drills, capacity-building, and community awareness programs
  • Push for greener maritime practices, including cleaner fuels and double-hulled tankers

As climate change intensifies and shipping traffic increases, protecting our coastal and marine heritage is no longer optional — it is imperative.

Context: China is set to embark on its next grand interplanetary venture with the imminent launch of the Tianwen-2 mission, a pioneering journey to a near-Earth asteroid and a distant comet in the asteroid belt. This ambitious dual-objective mission will significantly enhance China’s capabilities in asteroid sampling and deep space research.

Mission Overview: Tianwen-2 at a Glance

  • Launch Vehicle: Long March 3B
  • Launch Site: Xichang Satellite Launch Centre, Sichuan Province, China
  • Space Agency: China National Space Administration (CNSA)
  • Primary Objective:
    • Survey and collect samples from asteroid 469219 Kamo‘oalewa
    • Extended goal: Fly onwards to study comet 311P/PANSTARRS in the asteroid belt

Target Asteroid: Kamo‘oalewa — Earth’s Mysterious Companion

Discovered in 2016 by the Pan-STARRS 1 telescope in Hawaii, Kamo‘oalewa is a quasi-satellite of Earth — a rare class of celestial objects that orbit the Sun but stay gravitationally influenced by Earth.

Key Characteristics:

  • Appears to circle Earth, though it’s actually orbiting the Sun
  • Has been in its current orbit for approximately 100 years
  • Predicted to stay in a quasi-stable orbit for the next 300 years
  • Offers a unique opportunity to study a primitive remnant of early solar system material

Such quasi-satellites could one day serve as staging points for future lunar or Martian missions, given their relative proximity and accessibility.

Sampling Mechanism: Advanced Technology in Action

Tianwen-2 will employ the “touch-and-go” technique for sample collection — a method successfully demonstrated by:

  • NASA’s OSIRIS-REx (asteroid Bennu)
  • Japan’s Hayabusa2 (asteroid Ryugu)

Key Sampling Features:

  • The spacecraft will briefly hover over the asteroid, firing a projectile or gas burst to dislodge surface material, which is then collected.
  • A secondary sampling method — known as the “anchor-and-attach” technique — may also be deployed. This involves four robotic arms that can drill and extract subsurface material, allowing scientists to access more pristine samples.

Expanding Horizons: A Journey Beyond Kamo‘oalewa

Following the primary asteroid mission, Tianwen-2 will journey to comet 311P/PANSTARRS, a celestial object located in the asteroid belt. This phase aims to:

  • Study cometary activity
  • Observe dust ejection mechanisms
  • Analyze the composition of volatile-rich bodies, enhancing our understanding of solar system evolution

About the Tianwen Program: China’s Space Aspirations Soar

The Tianwen missions — named after “Heavenly Questions”, a classic poem by Qu Yuan — symbolize China’s deepening engagement with space exploration and scientific discovery.

Key Missions:

  • Tianwen-1 (2020):
    • China’s first Mars mission
    • Deployed an orbiter, lander, and the Zhurong rover
    • Marked China as only the second country to operate a rover on Mars
    • Zhurong operated successfully until 2022
  • Tianwen-3 (planned for 2028):
    • Aims to retrieve samples from Mars
    • Will position China alongside NASA and ESA in the elite club of interplanetary sample-return missions

Why Tianwen-2 Matters: A Scientific and Strategic Leap

  • Scientific Discovery: Provides vital clues to early solar system formation, asteroid composition, and the origin of water and organics on Earth.
  • Technological Advancement: Demonstrates China’s ability to execute complex, long-duration interplanetary missions.
  • Strategic Capability: Reinforces China’s position in the global space race, expanding its role in planetary defense, resource prospecting, and space diplomacy.
  • Potential for Future Mining: Missions like Tianwen-2 lay the groundwork for asteroid mining — tapping resources like platinum, nickel, and water ice that could fuel future space colonies.

Looking Ahead: A New Era in Asteroid Research

As nations look to the stars, asteroids and comets have become the next frontier for scientific breakthroughs and space-based industries. With Tianwen-2, China signals its determination to be a leading player in the cosmos, not just by reaching celestial bodies, but by bringing their secrets back to Earth.

Context: In a case that has reignited the national debate on free speech and dissent, the Supreme Court of India has granted interim bail to Ashoka University professor Ali Khan Mahmudabad, who was recently arrested in Haryana for controversial social media remarks linked to Operation Sindoor — India’s military operation targeting terrorist hubs in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir (PoK).

Though the Court provided temporary relief, it refused to stay the ongoing investigation, underlining the legal complexity and public sensitivity of the matter.

Criminal Allegations: A Web of Severe Charges

Professor Mahmudabad is facing multiple criminal charges under the newly introduced Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023, through two separate FIRs.

Charges in the First FIR:

  • Section 152: Punishes acts endangering national sovereignty and integrity (Replaces the old sedition law — maximum penalty: 7 years imprisonment).
  • Section 196(1)(b): Targets activities likely to disrupt communal harmony.
  • Section 197(1)(c): Deals with comments prejudicial to national integration.
  • Section 299: Criminalises deliberate insults to religious beliefs.

Charges in the Second FIR:

  • Section 79: Pertains to remarks insulting the modesty of a woman.
  • Section 353: Relates to statements inciting public mischief.

Key Concern: Section 152 remains the gravest charge, carrying a potential 7-year prison sentence, while other sections are punishable with up to 3 years of imprisonment.

Supreme Court’s Observations and Conditions for Bail

Professor Mahmudabad’s legal counsel argued that his posts were patriotic in nature and lacked criminal intent. However, the Supreme Court Bench, led by Justice Surya Kant, delivered a nuanced ruling.

Court’s Remarks:

  • Some phrases used by the professor had “dual meanings”, prompting the court to question his intent.
  • The Bench criticized the timing and language of the posts, suggesting they may have sought “cheap popularity” during a national crisis.

Conditions for Interim Bail:

  • Surrender of Passport: To prevent travel during the investigation.
  • Non-Interference: Professor must avoid discussing or commenting on the controversial posts.
  • Restricted Expression: No public comments on Operation Sindoor or the Pahalgam terror attack.
  • Full Cooperation: He must assist the investigation as directed.
  • No New FIRs: The Court prohibited the registration of additional FIRs regarding the same posts.
  • Formation of SIT: A three-member Special Investigation Team (SIT), composed of senior IPS officers from outside Haryana and Delhi, will assess the intent and impact of the professor’s statements.

Is ‘Unpatriotic’ Speech Still Protected Under the Constitution?

India’s Constitution under Article 19(1)(a) guarantees the right to freedom of speech and expression. However, this right is subject to reasonable restrictions listed under Article 19(2).

Permissible Restrictions Include:

  • Sovereignty and integrity of India
  • Security of the state
  • Public order
  • Decency or morality
  • Contempt of court
  • Defamation
  • Incitement to an offence
  • Friendly relations with foreign states

Importantly, courts have repeatedly ruled that any restriction must be narrowly defined and cannot be based on subjective interpretations of ‘patriotism’ or public sentiment.

Judicial Precedents Supporting Freedom of Expression:

Several landmark judgments have reaffirmed that even unpopular or offensive speech is protected under the Constitution:

Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015):

  • Section 66A of the IT Act was struck down.
  • The Court ruled that “disturbing” or “annoying” speech cannot be criminalised.
  • Affirmed that freedom of speech includes the right to express unpopular views.

Kaushal Kishore v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2023):

  • A Constitution Bench ruled that Article 19(2) is exhaustive and cannot be expanded.
  • Criticised the use of subjective morality to curb constitutional rights.

Concerns Over Judicial Consistency and Bias:

In a separate ruling earlier this year involving MP Imran Pratapgarhi, the Supreme Court clarified that free speech must be evaluated from the standpoint of a strong-minded and reasonable person, not an oversensitive or insecure audience.

However, critics have noted an increasingly inconsistent judicial approach to free speech:

  • Some judges appear influenced by popular sentiment, especially during national security crises.
  • There are concerns over deviation from past precedents, resulting in legal uncertainty and chilling effects on academic and journalistic freedom.

Why This Case Matters: The Larger Constitutional Debate

The case of Professor Mahmudabad goes beyond a single individual. It forces India to confront urgent constitutional questions:

  • Can academic dissent or anti-establishment opinions be criminalised?
  • Does social media expression, however controversial, deserve the same constitutional protection as print or broadcast speech?
  • Is the state using new laws like the BNS to silence critical voices in the name of national security?

As India navigates the digital age, cases like this will shape the boundaries of free expression, the responsibility of institutions, and the resilience of democratic values.

Did You Know?

  • Quasi-satellites, like Kamo‘oalewa, featured in China’s Tianwen-2 mission, are also challenging legal and scientific definitions — including questions about space resource ownership and international jurisdiction, reflecting a similar trend of global debates about authority, rights, and exploration.

Share:

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

1. India Meets Fiscal Deficit Target of 4.8% in FY25: A Step Toward Fiscal Prudence Context: In a significant achievement,...
1. Karnataka’s Bold Step Toward Protecting Gig Workers: The 2025 Ordinance Explained Context: In a significant move to modernise India’s...
1. New Defence Rulebook: Government Notifies Inter-Services Organisations Rules, 2025 Context: In a significant move to modernise India’s defence structure,...